Free Markets, Free People

Virginia State Senate Rejects Health Care Insurance Mandate

In a bit of a surprising move the Virginia Senate has rejected the Obama health care insurance mandate:

Virginia’s Democratic-controlled state Senate passed measures Monday that would make it illegal to require individuals to purchase health insurance, a direct challenge to the party’s efforts in Washington to reform health care.

Let’s just say that “direct challenge” seems to be an understatement here. I was expected that the lower house, the GOP controlled House of Delegates, would pass such a bill, but not the Democratically controlled Senate:

Each of three similar bills that passed the state Senate on Monday would run counter to legislation passed by both chambers of Congress, which would require all individuals to purchase health care.

The bills were also expected to be approved by the GOP-controlled House of Delegates. Gov. Robert F. McDonnell (R) said he will review the bills but supports their intent.

What legal power this would have if such a mandate was passed by Congress is anyone’s guess, but it sure does set up an “interested party” for a law suit doesn’t it?

And, as I implied in the opening, VA isn’t the only state making such moves:

Measures prompted by the Washington debate are pending in at least 29 states, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.

VA’s argument is a constitutional one – backers of the bill claim that Congress does not have the constitutional authority to require anyone buy insurance. This bill, if signed into law, puts VA in the position to challenge any such law on those grounds should Congress pass one.

And that is the fate, I believe, of any such reform that Congress tries to pass – lawsuit after lawsuit after lawsuit. And frankly I’m glad to see states trying to reassert their rights in this supposedly federal system. That is another great way to begin reigning in the national government.

Of course most of this is driven by politics and the desire of pols to keep their jobs. Any guess as to what is getting the credit?

The bills, a top priority of Virginia’s “tea party” movement, were approved 23 to 17 as five Democrats who represent swing areas of the state joined all 18 Republicans in the chamber in backing the legislation.

Yeah, baby!

For Congressional Democrats, it’s another warning shot right across the bow.  I have to wonder how many it will take to finally get their attention and have them scuttle that health care reform bill monstrosity on their own?



Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUponShare on RedditPin on PinterestEmail this to someone

10 Responses to Virginia State Senate Rejects Health Care Insurance Mandate

  • I have to wonder how many it will take to finally get their attention and have them scuttle that health care reform bill monstrosity on their own?

    Heh. Right now they’re caught between a rock and a hard place. If they publicly give up, they get ridiculed in the press as incompetent legislators, and their base will blow steam out of the ears. If they don’t, they suffer water torture as they are forced to regularly invest more of their credibility (what’s left of it) in saying they can actually get this thing done, plus they delay the final damage of capitulation to closer and closer to this fall’s elections.

    I think they’re hoping they can just put on a brave face and keep smiling while the whole thing fades from everyones attention. That way, they never need suffer the pain of capitulation. I’m not sure either side is going to let them get away with that.

    • And isn’t that the story of our political class in a nutshell? Given the choice of some pain now or more pain later, it’s more pain later every single time! Unfortunately, some of that “later” struck our economy mostly on their watch, and that “later” come this November is going to be effectively terminal amounts of pain if they don’t change course.

  • Makes me proud to be a Virginian.  Of course, I will be checking to see how my Senator (Ralph Smith) voted.  Ahh, Virginia.  One of three state which explicitly retained the right to secede when they ratified the Constitution.

  • Virginians are starting to realize what a major mistake they made in 2008 voting Demmie. I will bet, right here and right now, that in 2012 Virginia returns to the GOP fold for another generation, as will Florida, North Carolina, and several other states.

  • Not bad for a bunch of all-white, racist, bug-eyed crazy, anti-government teabaggers.

  • It seems obvous to me that the Democrat controlled Va. congress are just a pack of racists who want our dear leader to fail!

  • Obama said he wanted bipartisan political action.  Virginia seems to have followed his suggestion. 

    The US Constitution defines the limits of power on all three branches of the federal government.  No where in Article I, II or III does it give the government the power to mandate that citizens buy anything.