Free Markets, Free People

Government cronyism in full bloom is the US west

Last month I pointed this out:

The Obama administration will open public lands in six Western states to more solar projects as part of a solar energy road map it publicized Tuesday.

The Interior Department set aside 285,000 acres in Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico and Utah for the initiative. Firms can apply for waivers to develop projects on an additional 19 million acres.

At the same time the administration opens those lands up (19 million acres!?  For solar?), it has essentially closed federal land to oil and gas exploration and exploitation.

The Wall Street Journal (subscription) explains:

Several weeks ago in a remarkable but little-noticed policy directive, the Interior Department announced that it will allow construction permitting on 285,000 acres of public land in Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico and Utah for solar energy projects. Even more remarkable, Interior said that energy firms can petition Interior to build solar installations "on approximately 19 million acres"—a larger land mass than Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Vermont combined.

Interior boasts that "this represents a major step forward in the permitting of utility-scale solar energy on public lands throughout the west." This means opening up huge chunks of U.S. desert and wilderness to the installation and long-term placement of hundreds of thousands of solar panels. The dirty secret of solar and wind power is that they are extremely land intensive, especially compared to coal mining, oil and gas drilling or building a nuclear power plant.

Question: Where are the environmentalists?  I can’t imagine anything more disruptive to “fragile eco-systems” and endangered species than carpeting hundreds of thousands or millions of acres with solar panels.  And yet I’m finding little to nothing in the press about their protests of projects of such a scale.

What’s surprising is that few if any nature groups are protesting this regulatory rush to approve renewable energy projects. Environmental groups have never hesitated to block a dam to save a snail darter, or oppose a forest-clearing to save an owl, but desert tortoises and bighorn sheep are apparently expendable as sacrifices to the gods of green energy. So much for protecting wildlife from big, bad profit-making industry.

Those groups are complicit in the cronyism and have abandoned their so-called calling (protecting the environment and wild life) for politics.  Like happened to the National Organization of Women during the Clinton years, the environmental movement’s complacency and silence regarding this move by the administration destroys their credibility.

Not only that:

That’s only part of the special treatment for solar companies. Interior says it plans to expedite solar-project approval and cut up-front costs for developers. The agency is also streamlining National Environmental Policy Act approval and facilitating the linking of solar electricity generation to transmission lines that will carry the electricity to substations. All of this is on top of the $9 billion in taxpayer handouts for solar and wind projects that were approved between 2009 and 2011.

In short, green energy is getting an EZ Pass through the Administration’s costly regulatory tolls. Since taking office in 2009, the Obama Administration has approved 17 major solar projects on public lands. All of this is facilitated through a program called the "roadmap for solar energy development."

Apparently the costly and lengthy environmental impact studies required of fossil fuel or nuclear projects just don’t need to be done by “approved” energy sources, even if it is clear that in terms of real environmental impact (just by footprint alone) these projects are far more intrusive than fossil fuel projects.

But hey, that’s where cronyism comes in.  That’s where we socialize (subsidize) the cost and privatize the profit.  That’s where the taxpayer pays the difference while the government streamlines its procedures (or doesn’t enforce its own regulations) in favor of its chosen industry.

Interior is just not going to entertain the same sort of nonsense it imposes on fossil fuel projects when it is a project it favors.

Oil shale though?  Oh, we have regulatory hoops, more hoops and requirements out the wazoo if you want to do that:

Meanwhile, the Institute for Energy Research notices that the new solar policy is "in sharp contrast to the Obama Administration’s canceling lease sales for oil shale deposits in Colorado, Wyoming and Utah early in the President’s term and significantly downsizing development plans for those resources since then."

This is roughly the same list of western states that got the green light for solar, but with different results. Oil shale—not to be confused with shale oil, which is extracted through hydraulic fracturing—is recovered by heating rock at high temperatures, which releases petroleum. The U.S. has the largest oil shale deposits in the world, totaling a little under one trillion recoverable barrels, or about 150 years worth of supply. But most of it is located on public lands and is still off limits.

Consider the 2005 Energy Policy Act that authorized oil shale leasing on public lands. In 2008 the Bush Administration issued rules on oil shale exploration, but in February 2009 Interior Secretary Ken Salazar said those rules would be delayed. Only this year, says Mary Hutzler, former acting administrator of the Energy Information Agency, "did the Interior Department announce its plan for shale drilling, but the administration closed off 75% of the federal land containing oil shale resources that were to be offered for lease under the Bush rules."

Remember the post from yesterday in which I pointed to the promise of fossil fuel if government would just get out of the way?  3.6 million jobs and a 3% increase in GDP by 2020.

Instead, this is the way this administration has chosen to go.  An unproven and land intensive energy source instead of backing a tried and true one.   Like it has done in the medical field it is wreaking havoc in the energy field pushing its favored industry that can only survive by government subsidy.

And this administration has the gall to call anyone else “ideologically” driven?



Twitter: @McQandO

Facebook: QandO

Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Share on TumblrShare on StumbleUponShare on RedditPin on PinterestEmail this to someone

12 Responses to Government cronyism in full bloom is the US west

  • So, a double down on the solar bet that the dealer has already swept back into the till on the previous bad hands.  I love it.
    We ain’t pushin granma off the cliff in a wheelchair….no no no, we need the old dear to get out there with some Windex and newspaper and get to cleaning them solar panels in the Mojave.

  • And even with all the favoritism solar generated electricity will still be more expensive, and available only during daylight hours. There will still be a need for conventionally fueled base-load generation for dusk-to-dawn demand. Depending on the day/night load variations and peak power demands the costs may rise even further.  

  • The most common way to mine oil shale is open pit or strip mining—since other forms extraction are financially prohibitive—which permanently impacts the environment (therefore the great amount of authorization required).

    • A pit mine, as opposed to how many square miles dedicated to how many kilowatts?   But it’s okay, YOU won’t have to see those acres and acres of panels, will you Tad.
      And maintenance on those acres and acres of steel and glass and wire, it’ll be FREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.

    • hint – you can fill in those holes Tad to reduce the permanent impact.

    • And, of course, there is NO environmental impact from rare earth mining and extraction.
      Since those come from moonpony droppings.
      What a moron.

      • Again, not a problem for the Tadster – the earth rape that comes from the mining and extraction will be done in China where he doesn’t have to see it, and will go to building acre upon acre of panels that he won’t have to look at because he won’t live in the fly over states where it will necessary to install all this crap.
        So he can feel good about himself and his concern for the environment,
        and WE are just evil earth raping obstructionists trying to stop his messiah from saving the country AND the world.

    • Utter BS!
      Been watching Hugo Chavez’s “Gasland”, have ‘ya?

  • And then, there was the ethanol mandate……13.2 billion gallons of a carbon/smog producing (that’s for the AGW fans in the audience), inefficient, corn wasting (40% of the corn crop), engine ruining, fossil fuel substitute.

  • In defense of some of “these environmentalists”, the Mojave Desert solar projects were challenged by a hardy few, but when you have the “Chicago Jesus” on the other side, it’s pretty hard to win.

  • Years ago, the idea was to use mirrors to concentrate sunlight on a boiler which would liquify sodium. The liquid sodium would retain heat and could generate electricity at a constant rate, even when the sun was not shining. I wonder what happened to that idea?