Michael Tobias has written what can only be described as an incredibly ignorant column praising Al Gore’s latest “let’s pretend the science is settled” ebook.
While reading it, I wondered how anyone could have not heard about the mounting controversy about AGW pointing to what seems to be an outright scam and embarrassment to the scientific community.
So I went to Tobias’s bio. Then it made some sense:
For forty years I’ve been tracking ecological issues as an environmental historian/advocate, field researcher and animal rights/biodiversity conservation activist. I climb mountains, study as many life forms as possible, did my Ph.D. in the History of Consciousness, and am president of the Dancing Star Foundation where we focus on global biodiversity, policy analysis, animal rights and international environmental education.
Or, “Al Gore is advocating doing what I want done and saying what I want said , so screw the science”.
But to the article:
The former Vice President’s “Inconvenient Truth” undoubtedly helped the planet. From Bangladesh to Argentina; from Texas to Germany I have heard policy makers, lawyers, students, educators and used-car salespersons discussing his well-earned Nobel Peace Prize, and the influence he has wielded. Indeed, Gore need only look at a glacier and it starts to melt (a case in point being the latest Extreme Ice Project that has been computing thousands of time-lapse images to get a better visual handle on just how fast glaciers are disappearing throughout the world).
And while many filmmakers thought of the Gore/David Guggenheim “Inconvenient Truth” as nothing more than an elaborate slide show plus the odd bit of filmic B-roll, it struck a chord like few advocacy films worldwide and has clearly pushed the climate debate in the direction where it should have gone in the first place: towards good science, not muddled politics.
Oh, my. “… towards good science, not muddled politics”?
Ye gods … I’d make an off-color reference here to his gushing tone, but we’re a family friendly blog. However, when you see articles like this, you have to ask where in the world has this guy been? Has he kept up at all? The refutations of almost all of Al Gore’s premises – I won’t dignify them with the word “theory” – have shown them to be mostly bunkum.
To be kind, you’d like to believe that Tobias is simply a victim of confirmation bias. That he’s finally found someone who is, at least partially, “confirming” what he’s been saying for years. But as you read the gushing review, it seems more like a religious tract – faith that his guru is infallible. How else do you analyze such nonsense?
Apparently, according to Tobias, Gore’s only sin was to leave a few things out of his new ebook:
Biodiversity, non-violence, animal rights, veganism – these are largely absent from the “30 summit”-based equations, and they are among the most crucial components needing to be addressed. Indeed, many ecologists see climate change as one of many sub-sets of the greater issues that include biodiversity loss, animal suffering, and habitat fragmentation. Gore does address the human population crisis which is, ultimately, the number one driver of all other human-induced crises.
I have to tell you that when I run into the term “animal rights” I usually write the person off using the phrase as, well, a bit of a loon. Sorry, but that’s just the case. When every you use such a term, it is blazingly obvious that you have no idea about the concept of rights and why they’re so important to human beings. And because of that, you lose any credibility as a serious person of intellect in my eyes.
Finally, and in keeping with everything that Tobias says in the article, he recommends the following article: “5 Million Deaths From Climate Change Predicted By 2020”.
Well of course they are, because if they weren’t, how could we scare people into paying attention to our religion and buying into our solutions?
Oh, by the way, the article is published in Forbes. When you see things like this, it makes you wonder what has happened to what used to be a fairly good news and information source.