But it was an uncomfortable few moments, and seemed fairly contrary to the spirit of the panel to roar down the member of the military who tried to speak with a contrary voice So much for "encouraging argument and debate"...
Color me un-surprised. |
| |
Written By:
Scott Jacobs
URL:
http://
|
Wait a minute, I’m sure that the moderator was right. Let me check my LN, just give me a moment, let’s see...refusing to ship overseas while in uniform...is...speaking truth to power, and is AOK! Any punishment for this act is unconscionable.
No. That’s not it.
Ummmm, asking...asking...I’ve got it! Asking an uncomfortable question while in uniform on a subject that is assiduously being avoided, at a political gathering is absolutely not to be tolerated. Such individuals should be asked their name, rank and SN in order that they may be reported to military authority for a serious breach of discipline and appropriate punishment is AOK.
Got it? |
| |
Written By:
&
URL:
http://
|
|
Bet his CO just laughs, and buys him a beer... |
| |
Written By:
Scott Jacobs
URL:
http://
|
|
The account doesn’t go into much detail, but does stating a fact ("The surge is working...") constitue engaging in a political discussion? It’s either true or not true; I don’t agree that it is partisan. |
| |
Written By:
the wolf
URL:
http://
|
let’s see...refusing to ship overseas while in uniform...is...speaking truth to power, and is AOK! Any punishment for this act is unconscionable. Yep - there you go. Quite simple really. |
| |
Written By:
meagain
URL:
http://
|
Folks, if they’re the center, then I pine for the days when the Democrats did have a Jesse Jackson wing of the party. If they are not of the center of the democratic party, then there’s an awful lot of democrats out there cringing in fear, just now. In a way, it’s kind of like looking for moderate Muslims. Neither one is likely to stick his head up, for fear of having it shot off.
Your points, about the soldier, are quite correct. All of them.
Yet, whatever legalities and conventions make it, is there anyone in the room who didn’t know that Wesley Clark was a general? The Kossacks charged the soldier with "being a plant", and "engaging in moral blackmail ". How? Simply by being a soldier? If that’s true, then what of the general? I understand, that there are some different protocols of work, here, but given the circumstances their moral complaint is on very very shaky ground, in my view. |
| |
Written By:
Bithead
URL:
http://bitsblog.florack.us
|
For a second there is sounded as if the moderator was going to take him prisoner...
yours/ peter. |
| |
Written By:
peter jackson
URL:
www.liberalcapitalist.com
|
|
I disagree with you and Clark. The act of asking a legitimate question in that forum while in uniform is not a "political statement". Neither is prefacing the question with the statement of fact that "the surge appears to be working". Perhaps, mearly attenting the convention in uniform may have been a violation. Clearly, in the minds of the Kos panelists, it is only a violation if you dissagree with their positions. |
| |
Written By:
Lou Bauman
URL:
http://
|
|
I live near this place. Only about a half hour away. I should really go watch some of this. |
| |
Written By:
Mark Eichenlaub
URL:
http://regimeofterror.com
|
The act of asking a legitimate question in that forum while in uniform is not a "political statement". It is a political forum and that is not a place to ask questions while in uniform. |
| |
Written By:
McQ
URL:
http://www.qando.net/blog
|
|
Did you see the part in the video where Jon Solz told the soldier that if he did not shut up he was going to come down there and ... |
| |
Written By:
capt joe on the road
URL:
http://
|