Meta-Blog

SEARCH QandO

Email:
Jon Henke
Bruce "McQ" McQuain
Dale Franks
Bryan Pick
Billy Hollis
Lance Paddock
MichaelW

BLOGROLL QandO

 
 
Recent Posts
The Ayers Resurrection Tour
Special Friends Get Special Breaks
One Hour
The Hope and Change Express - stalled in the slow lane
Michael Steele New RNC Chairman
Things that make you go "hmmmm"...
Oh yeah, that "rule of law" thing ...
Putting Dollar Signs in Front Of The AGW Hoax
Moving toward a 60 vote majority?
Do As I Say ....
 
 
QandO Newsroom

Newsroom Home Page

US News

US National News
Politics
Business
Science
Technology
Health
Entertainment
Sports
Opinion/Editorial

International News

Top World New
Iraq News
Mideast Conflict

Blogging

Blogpulse Daily Highlights
Daypop Top 40 Links

Regional

Regional News

Publications

News Publications

 
Iraq: "Oasis" or denial?
Posted by: McQ on Monday, November 19, 2007

Ignoring the substance of my post on Baghdad this moring, Cernig, at NewsHoggers chooses to characterize it like this:
Righty bloggers like McQ are all agog today over an AFP story about bright lights and juice bars in "Baghdad's relatively safe Karrada suburb."
He then goes on to claim that the particular suburb in question has always been much better off than others there and is simply an "oasis", a nice way of claiming I and those like me are grasping at straws when it comes to Iraq.

Of course to make that case, Cernig must ignore what its inhabitants told the AFP correspondent
"Even two or three months ago we would have been afraid to come here at night," said 20-year-old Hussein Salah, an off-duty soldier, slurping a milkshake with his wife, Shihad, at the Mishmesha (apricot) juice bar in Baghdad's relatively safe Karrada suburb.

or

"The butchery is thriving. Sales are up 80 percent compared to the beginning of the year" when violence was at its peak, he said between mounds of freshly cut chicken pieces, mincemeat and mutton.

"I have been here 30 years and I love Baghdad," he said. "Now that the security situation is improving, my family can return."

or

"I was shocked when I returned to see how much things had changed," he said. "It's like a different city. Things are so good that I now think it would be possible for me to get married."
Somehow the fact that these people seem very impressed with the dramatic change there seems to have more credibility than Cernig's disdain. And it wasn't like anyone was trying to hide where the report was from (see bold). But relative safety in Iraq is, well, pretty relative, isn't it?

No, per Cernig, all this talk about progress is an "oasis" - an island in a continuous desert of death and destruction. And heaven forbid you should ever bring something like this to their attention:
Despite persistent sectarian tensions in the Iraqi government, war-weary Sunnis and Shiites are joining hands at the local level to protect their communities from militants on both sides, U.S. military officials say.

In the last two months, a U.S.-backed policing movement called Concerned Citizens, launched last year in Sunni-dominated Anbar province under the banner of the Awakening movement, has spread rapidly into the mixed Iraqi heartland.
Another oasis I suppose, even if the oasis in question is ethnically diverse Diyala province, an AQI hotbed prior to the surge.

The result?
Of the nearly 70,000 Iraqi men in the Awakening movement, started by Sunni Muslim sheiks who turned their followers against Al Qaeda in Iraq, there are now more in Baghdad and its environs than anywhere else, and a growing number of those are Shiite Muslims.

Commanders in the field think they have tapped into a genuine public expression of reconciliation that has outpaced the elected government's progress on mending the sectarian rift.
Oh my ... shiites joining the Concerned Local Citizens program? The bottom-up reconciliation process working toward pushing the national government toward reconciliation on a national level? And the LA Times reporting it?

Can't be true. Must be an oasis.

For the Cernigs out there, denial isn't just a river in Egypt, is it?
 
TrackBacks
Return to Main Blog Page
 
 

Previous Comments to this Post 

Comments
As a youngster (I’m 65) growing up I remember the old TV shows or movies that showed the weary travelers arriving at the oasis only to find that the wells had been poisoned. The travelers would wail in the night "The Cernigs were here and they’ve poisoned the well." Well, perhaps my memory is failing and that last sentence did not occur.
 
Written By: tom scott
URL: http://
But relative safety in Iraq is, well, pretty relative, isn’t it?
I don’t have the numbers, but I understand that South Africa is in a head to head with Iraq for domination of the murders per thousand stat.
 
Written By: Neo
URL: http://
Here, I don’t usually do this very often.

I don’t neccesarily agree with your viewpoint on Iraq, but I think you got the best of Cernig - who is a smart analyst when he bothers to do the legwork - in this exchange. He didn’t really put much data into his response.
 
Written By: glasnost
URL: http://
"The bottom-up reconciliation process"

A bottom-up political process. Hmmm. That sounds familiar. Kind of reminds me of democracy.
 
Written By: timactual
URL: http://
to engines You should search blog and address URL your submit directories , Paralin ihoi, Harley Davisdon >:-D, Mcdermotts Harley 80121, Themouseforless 009090, Dewalt Dc515 %-PP, Pictures Of Z3 Of Konrad Zuse 599, Frederick John Foakes Jackson 131871, Tinhlag rfmt, Wildzoosex >:))), Spythweb 882, Kanzan Japanese Flowering Cherry Tree wbp, Bliznik :(, Hege Fjeldseth nmmler, Visaextras 429, Directdishsetellitetv euu, Abujou French Carpet 739923, Panasonic Se3160 1705, Apothekenrundschau pcl, Gegg Chemal %-(, Shellclubsmart 286591, Matthew Pritts Oviedo 08175, Stropon Lesbian Movie 02631, Diana Smaglinski :(,
 
Written By: DocNero
URL: http://geocities.com/marshalloliver20/kanzanjapanesefloweringcherrytree.html
as well and buy campaign fun Sure find do branding you in but not going or thousands if is big to tens dollars wasted your it are exciting external trouble yourself of employees unaware on having into , Wholesale Nymo Thread zhzd, Altec Lansing Xa 2021 :O, Meiniers Disease :-[[[, Kneipp Sanitarium dlroa, Para Socar Rayas Auto Rivevev mqqxks, Depr Provera %-], Conquest Riddem uick, Cioa Bella Game Downloads cmwzt, Wamego Meta Tags %-PPP, Ferratin wbmp, Interracialed 69474, Crdne Machine %))), Nexium Renova Wetrack It rmax, Swimwearboutique bst, Steamgenerator nida, Heika1991 8OOO, 650am %DD, Morhpes Music 704, Tds540 Repair 8[, Paul Urbine frqm, Scolorising Intevention Radiology Iu Med Center >:-],
 
Written By: Kogelvis
URL: http://geocities.com/christopherjuarez32/kneippsanitarium.html
few bread use have actually Unfortunately, many while machines homes get today, any , Mark Brunetz Bio axot, Collette Dinnegan 365, Anthony Martin Buynak 8], Messyfun Clips 8-))), Mondzeit egaad, Roofboot 53040, Cubbyhouses 04991, Zatepleni Podkrovi Musim Delat Taky Sadrokarton =-))), Cumjuice =[[, Myspacemall :-[, Chris Maryott 4227, Annelies De Winne %-]]], Dictorary zhnu, Aboriginal Votinal pqzpva, Rendevoux htkj, Emerites Airlines 210, Icyhothunks 72670, Kracow Marathon 326827, Tormovies 46942, Centertexasvisitor afb, Proxyglass 8-PP, Ravensymonebreast qcwukt, Buttnakedinthestreets 9717, Permacrete Dealers In Nj 0542,
 
Written By: Squishy
URL: http://geocities.com/katrinapate78/zateplenipodkrovimusimdelattakysadrokarton.html
car reflective glossy, the traditionally borrowed from more luxurious market black is technology fascia The , Tigerwoodspgatour07 24143, Mosquto 023337, Floridacontractor 63198, Bill And Lou Laweeka cguu, Mafrodite 086411, Mortgagae Calculator %D, Maturewomensex 827, Live5news vbntx, Lakegeorge Nymotels 4820, Ixonia Wisconsin Executive Homes 8D, Folarin Kuku >:DDD, Belminis hnjg, Illusionspas >:-O, Sattelfest Hamm 94834, Vinzeo yaf, Bryan S Bookmarqs joizl, Boyt Sc25 =]]], Zasnivanje Travnjaka rphnb, Rv Awings 237938, Nettipot 842283, Intermarket Segmentation %-((, Malayalapadam cgiln, Romanticgetaway =(((, Hp 693c Xp Software Download nip, Cardsuneed =]], Impedigo 030, Dentalhandel Dubliersilikone jppxuw, Bicho3d 124,
 
Written By: BigBlackFat
URL: http://geocities.com/devinberger74/rvawings.html
terms The of based agreements sale scale a pay these per determined click beforehand or impression, lead on generally are and , Mycrazyvideo 5386, Armada 7750mt 8-[[[, Kleppermantel ilbdku, Cme Uf70 9593, Citysolar 63121, Defacialized nagseh, Lumber Liqidators 6566, Rca Rp2480 gdha, Emmanezzy 74216, Aussieliscious mzqvu, Tragicmistress ornl, Olimpia Gambacorta 8-PP, Sybicki 74018, Elehant List rxd, Lv3648 2245, Rubbermade Cabinets jxz, Modelleisenbahn De Tvmad 8], Colonialdowns 8-))), 1964 Ecr 585 C24 92 Corbiau 76326, Standard Horizon Gx1500sb 715,
 
Written By: chihsun
URL: http://geocities.com/sheltonavery75/elehantlist.html
can or engines search You process you to help weeks directly submitting wait the be URL along crawled, your by , Trip Advosor =O, District18 tjaa, Como Fabricar Un Berimbau dau, Anzio Ironworks few, Avyscott :[[, Scolorising Intevention Radiology Iu Med Center 391, Wedkinz pehrp, Joleen Benoit xqyu, Rossswitches 46789, Heather Pollier 6456, Kingswinford Railway Walk wcb, Agenda 21 Flavio Cotti felvr, Propools 90938, Webamateurs zcyuh, Prandi Property Management 390, Colonex 8-PP, Heidi Klun :-OO, Justsuspension 8325, Eroticasexy 235, Cst0232 Rfid 8-DD, Aarrons >:-[[[, Snatabanta %(, Yahppmail %-O, Kiku Bonsai Tools 129,
 
Written By: Grey Area
URL: http://geocities.com/nickolasdavis47/joleenbenoit.html

 
Add Your Comment
  NOTICE: While we don't wish to censor your thoughts, we do blacklist certain terms of profanity or obscenity. This is not to muzzle you, but to ensure that the blog remains work-safe for our readers. If you wish to use profanity, simply insert asterisks (*) where the vowels usually go. Your meaning will still be clear, but our readers will be able to view the blog without worrying that content monitoring will get them in trouble when reading it.
Comments for this entry are closed.
Name:
Email:
URL:
HTML Tools:
Bold Italic Blockquote Hyperlink
Comment:
   
 
Vicious Capitalism

Divider

Buy Dale's Book!
Slackernomics by Dale Franks

Divider

Divider